4 Beliefs That Destroy Self-Trust (And How to Overcome Them)
Self-trust is the foundation of confidence, resilience, and success. It’s what allows us to make decisions with conviction, take risks, and navigate life’s challenges without constantly second-guessing ourselves. But many of us struggle with self-trust because of deeply ingrained beliefs that hold us back. These beliefs often go unnoticed, yet they sabotage our ability to trust our own judgment, make decisions, and move forward confidently.
Let’s break down four of the most harmful beliefs that erode self-trust and explore how to overcome them.
1. The Fear That You Can’t Handle Consequences
One of the biggest reasons people hesitate to trust themselves is the fear that they won’t be able to handle what happens if they make the “wrong” decision. This belief keeps you stuck in indecision, overanalyzing every possible outcome, and avoiding choices altogether.
At its core, this fear comes from a lack of confidence in your ability to adapt, problem-solve, and recover. It makes every decision feel like a life-or-death scenario, when in reality, most choices are reversible or manageable.
How to Overcome It:
- Reframe your fear: Instead of asking, “What if this goes wrong?” ask, “What if I can handle it no matter what?”
- Look at your past resilience: Think about difficult situations you’ve navigated before. You’ve likely faced setbacks and survived them—what makes this time different?
- Take action despite fear: Recognize that fear doesn’t mean danger—it just means uncertainty. The more decisions you make, the more you prove to yourself that you can handle their consequences.
When we resist the possibility of mistakes or discomfort, we often end up resisting life itself. Learning how to accept what is can be a powerful antidote to fear-based decision paralysis.
2. The “Magic Bullet” Mindset
Many people hesitate to trust their own decisions because they believe there’s a single perfect solution one “magic bullet” that will guarantee success, happiness, or security. This belief makes every decision feel like a high-stakes gamble, where choosing wrong means failure.
The problem? Life doesn’t work that way. Most decisions are not binary, and multiple paths can lead to success. When you cling to the idea of a perfect answer, you delay action, waiting for absolute certainty that will never come.
How to Overcome It:
- Accept that perfect solutions don’t exist: Instead of trying to find the “best” decision, aim for a “good enough” one that aligns with your values and goals.
- Commit to learning along the way: Every decision provides feedback. If something doesn’t work out, you gain insight that helps you make better choices in the future.
- Take small steps instead of waiting for clarity: Clarity comes from action, not endless thinking. Start with small, low-risk decisions and build confidence as you go.
3. The Belief That Someone Else Has a Better Idea
Do you find yourself constantly looking for external validation before making a decision? Do you assume that other people experts, mentors, friends know better than you? While seeking advice can be helpful, constantly deferring to others erodes your self-trust.
This belief stems from a fear of making mistakes and a tendency to underestimate your own knowledge, intuition, and experience. You might tell yourself, “I’m not qualified enough” or “I don’t know enough to decide.” But the truth is, no one knows your life, goals, and desires better than you do.
How to Overcome It:
- Recognize that others are not always right: Even experts get things wrong. Just because someone else has an opinion doesn’t mean it’s the best choice for you.
- Balance external input with internal wisdom: Gather advice, but always ask yourself: “Does this feel right for me?”
- Practice making decisions without outside input: Challenge yourself to make small daily decisions—what to eat, what to wear, what to do next—without asking anyone else for their opinion.
If fear keeps you paralysed, this post on facing fear and building resilience offers practical tools to help you move forward.
4. The Need for Permission to Make a Decision
Many people struggle with self-trust because they subconsciously wait for someone else to “approve” their choices. This often stems from childhood conditioning—if you were taught to always seek permission before acting, you may carry that mindset into adulthood.
This belief manifests as hesitation, procrastination, and a reliance on external validation before taking action. It keeps you in a passive role, waiting for someone else to tell you it’s okay to move forward.
How to Overcome It:
- Acknowledge your autonomy: You are an adult. You do not need permission to pursue your goals, change your mind, or make decisions for your own life.
- Start small: If making big decisions feels overwhelming, start by asserting your independence in low-risk areas. Choose where to eat, what to watch, or how to spend your free time without asking for input.
- Affirm your right to decide: Remind yourself, “I am capable of making decisions for myself.” Say it out loud if needed.
Self-trust grows when you get to know your true self. This piece can help you reconnect to that.
Final Thoughts
Self-trust is like a muscle it strengthens with use. The more you make decisions, face challenges, and trust your ability to handle the outcomes, the more confidence you build.
The key is to recognize these self-sabotaging beliefs when they arise and actively challenge them. You are capable, resilient, and equipped to make good decisions for yourself. The only thing standing in your way is the belief that you can’t.
So take that first step. Trust yourself. You’ve got this.
Want support exploring your schemas and shifting old emotional patterns?
You don’t have to do it alone. I’d be honoured to walk with you.
